By
Azizah al-Hibri
Boston Globe, 9/11/2002, p.A23
THE
RIPPLE effects of the attacks on the United States a year
ago continue to unfold. At first there was the enormous
loss of life, the malicious destruction of American symbols,
and the somber and grief-stricken nation huddling together
in unity, defiance, and anticipation.
At
the Washington National Cathedral, President Bush invited
an imam to join him in the National Day of Prayer and Remembrance.
In many American cities, non-Muslims protected neighboring
mosques from the wrath of the misguided. They instinctively
understood that we were all in this together and that Muslims
were victimized by the attacks alongside their compatriots.
After all, missiles do not inquire about one's religion.
A
year later, consequences continue to build up. Those in
charge of our safety inform us that another attack will
surely occur, and when it does it will be another horrific
one. We feel helpless, angry, and exposed. Yet we go to
work every day trying to rebuild the pension nest egg we
lost because some corrupt executives cheated the nation
out of its delicate recovery. We continue to act as if tomorrow
will be just another day.
It
is getting harder for Muslims to act that way. Unlike their
compatriots, they have had to bear multiple burdens. They
suffered human losses and will again. They suffered from
growing suspicion about ''sleeper cells'' in their midst.
They suffered government raids on their homes and their
educational and charitable institutions. There were secret
detentions, profiling, and secret evidence used against
many of them; devices that stretched our constitutional
limits to accommodate urgent security concerns.
Then,
when no one thought things could get worse, they did. In
July a member of the U.S. Civil Rights Commission reminded
Muslims of the possibility of their internment if there
is another attack on U.S. soil.
Those
comments were rejected by the full panel. But that was only
the beginning. An attack from the ''religious right'' followed
soon after. It maligned everything the Muslims held sacred.
Those who were known for their vehement opposition to intolerance
and incivility in the public square tepidly objected. The
situation started to resemble that of America in the 18th
century, when Islam was freely referred to as a ''false
religion'' and our prophet as a great ''impostor.'' Muslim
regimes then as now restricted freedom of speech, and they
were recklessly viewed as the embodiment of Islamic principles.
It
may not be a known fact that some minority leaders have
blamed Muslims for the recent erosion of civil liberties.
Some Muslims have blamed others within their community because
they came from the same ethnic background as the terrorists.
Those blamed are in a daze. They have not yet fathomed the
horrendous events and refuse to own them. Why should they?
After all, how many Christians owned the Oklahoma City bombing?
In
the midst of their pain, American Muslims know that they
cannot prevent another attack. No terrorist asked for their
opinion in the first instance; nor did the terrorists of
9/11 seem to have had the welfare of American Muslims at
heart. Otherwise, why would hundreds of Muslims perish in
the World Trade Center? Why would the terrorists expose
American Muslims to a catastrophic backlash just about the
time that Muslims were beginning to find their own voice
within this society?
So
let us be very clear: These attacks were not about the world
of religion and spirituality. They were about the assertion
of a brute worldly power, power that willfully harms and
destroys people, symbols, and our peace of mind.
The
America I knew and loved should not become the casualty
of 9/11.
I
am not afraid of internment if God chooses it for me. Nor
do I have children whose future needs to be secured. When
I arrived in this country years ago I read about the McCarthy
era, the Japanese internment camps, the forced conversion
of enslaved African Muslims, and the genocidal wars against
the natives of this country. As time passed, I saw a mature
country struggling to get out from under this painful heritage,
into the sun of true liberty and remarkable diversity, and
I loved it, warts and all.
My
country was never perfect, nor will it be, but at least
I have the constitutional right and the caring heart to
try to make it so. I will not let any terrorist take that
away from me or from you. God willing, I shall succeed.
Azizah
al-Hibri is a professor of law at University of Richmond
and executive director of KARAMAH: MUSLIM WOMEN LAWYERS
FOR HUMAN RIGHTS.